Closing RFE objections on "Memberships"

• No requirement for outstanding achievements

  The officer does not see that membership is granted specifically for outstanding achievements as a required condition.

• Ordinary admission criteria

  Requirements such as working in the field, education, experience, activity, payment of dues, or recommendations are not considered sufficient.

• The association was not proven to be field-specific

  The officer states that the association's connection to the beneficiary's field of activity was not proven.

• No evaluation by recognized experts

  It was not shown that the candidate's outstanding achievements were evaluated by recognized national or international experts.

• Membership level is unclear

  The documents do not show the membership level or whether privileged levels differ from ordinary participation.

• Insufficient membership documents

  The officer cites plain language and requires direct evidence of the membership itself, the association's field-specific nature, and strict admission criteria.