Skip to content

RFE objection "No requirement for outstanding achievements": how it was answered

Key answer

The officer does not see that membership is granted specifically for outstanding achievements as a required condition. Add the bylaws, admission rules, and a letter from the association directly stating that admission is based on the candidate's outstanding achievements.

The objection belongs to the "Memberships" criterion. Below is what the community did to close it: the order of steps, the documents that were attached and the wording that went into the answer.

Steps that closed it

  1. Show that membership is not open or paid, but requires selection based on outstanding achievements
  2. Provide admission rules with criteria for evaluating candidates
  3. Prove that the admission decision is made by recognized experts in the field
  4. Connect the membership criteria specifically to professional achievements, not to experience, education, or payment of dues
  5. Add a letter from the organization explaining the selection process and level of requirements
  6. Show a low acceptance rate or competitive selection, if applicable

What was attached

  • Organization bylaws or regulations with membership requirements
  • Description of the nomination, review, and voting process
  • Letter from the organization stating that membership is granted only for outstanding achievements
  • Profiles of committee members or experts who make decisions
  • Statistics on applications and accepted members
  • Screenshots of the official website with selection criteria
  • Documents confirming the petitioner's achievements on the basis of which membership was granted

How the answer was worded

Membership in the organization is not granted automatically or in exchange for payment of dues, but only after expert evaluation of the candidate's professional achievements. Candidates must be nominated, submit evidence of a significant contribution to the field, undergo review by an expert committee, and receive approval based on verified outstanding results.

A pattern, not a template to copy: the wording only works with your own facts behind it.

Where to check this

Other objections on this criterion

Reference information and community experience, not legal advice. The AAO figures are lessons from appeals, not approval odds; fees and timelines change - verify on uscis.gov.