All EB-1A appeals
EB-1A appeals: Business
143 real anonymized AAO decisions on the EB-1A talent visa in Business - with the criteria and reasons broken down per case. These are appeals (mostly denials): a base for studying real reasons, not approval statistics.
Outcomes
Dismissed: 106 (74%) · remanded: 33 (23%) · sustained: 4 (3%)
Criteria in this field
Counted most: Leading role, Judging, Published material about you; NOT counted most: Awards, Original contribution, Published material about you
All cases (143)
- Entrepreneur2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Business and Social Psychology2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Law/Legal Entrepreneurship2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/6
- Social Entrepreneurship2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Business and immigration investment2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Accounting and Business Operations Management2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Financial Technology/Entrepreneurship2025 · case remanded · criteria 2/6
- Business (Business Consultant and Executive)2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Logistics Consulting/Business2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/1
- Administrative Services and Facilities Management2025 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Safety and Risk Management2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Retail Management2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business (marketplace entrepreneur/e-commerce)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Business2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/4
- Business (Vaccine Industry)2024 · case remanded · criteria 2/4
- Financial and Investment Analysis2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/4
- Business (Business Development Executive)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Business (Capital Management/Venture Capital)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/3
- Project Management / Eco-friendly Products (stated field)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Business2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Business2024 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- Finance and Accounting2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/5
- Business Executive2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Real Estate2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Financial Technology/Business2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/3
- Management Information Systems2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Business2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/1
- Business2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Business (Energy Sector)2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Business (Forensic Investigations, Fraud Prevention, Information Security)2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/6
- Law and Religion (ultimately determined to be Business)2024 · case remanded · criteria 5/5
- Construction Industry / Entrepreneurship2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Financial Technology/Business2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/6
- Business (Furniture)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Business (Pomegranate Industry)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Law and Economics (formerly Professor)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Business/Technology (Snow Removal & Sanitation Services, Invention)2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/4
- Business (Investment Fund Management)2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Business (New Market Business Strategist)2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/7
- Technology (Product Development and Management)2024 · case remanded · criteria 4/4
- Law and Economics2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Manufacturing eco-friendly products (Business)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Economics2024 · appeal sustained · criteria 6/7
- Business (Beverage Industry, Caribbean Trade, Coconut Industry, Entrepreneurship)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/3
- Entrepreneurship/Real Estate Development2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Business (Chief Financial Officer)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Management Consulting2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Product Management (Technology)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 5/8
- Business (Attorney/Law)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/7
- Business2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/2
- Financial Management/Venture Capital2024 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Business (General and Operations Manager)2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Entrepreneurship, City Counseling, Philanthropy2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business Executive2024 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- Economics2024 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business (Restaurant Management)2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/6
- Business Sustainability2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Business2023 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- small business development2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Business2023 · case remanded · criteria 0/1
- Business (Corporate Product Strategy)2023 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Project Management (Senior Project Manager)2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Entrepreneurship and Business Development2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality (Project Management)2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Personnel Management Consulting / Human Resources2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business2023 · case remanded · criteria 0/1
- Business (Gender, Diversity, and Inclusion)2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Business2023 · appeal sustained · criteria 5/5
- Entrepreneurship/Business2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Business2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/4
- Business2023 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- Administrative Services Management2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Business (Big Data Center Consultant)2023 · appeal sustained · criteria 3/3
- Business (Plant Accountant)2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/6
- Capital Management2023 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Asset Management (Insurance and Pensions)2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/6
- Business (Weight Loss Center)2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/5
- Administrative Services Management2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Business (Solutions Architect/CEO)2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Business Operations2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/3
- Business2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Tax Accounting2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/5
- Business2022 · case remanded · criteria 2/3
- Business (Transnational Corporate Law)2022 · case remanded · criteria 3/3
- Oil and Gas Industry (Business)2022 · appeal sustained · criteria 5/6
- Business2022 · case remanded · criteria 2/6
- Business2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Hospitality/Business2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/5
- Economics2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Economic History2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/3
- Business (Tax Consultant)2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/7
- Business (Fund Management)2022 · case remanded · criteria 4/5
- Entertainment (Executive Producer)2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Business2022 · case remanded · criteria 1/1
- Business2022 · case remanded · criteria 1/3
- Real Estate Development2022 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Administrative Services Management2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/8
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 4/4
- Administrative Services Management2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/6
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/5
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Tax Accounting2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 4/5
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/5
- Media/Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/4
- Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/2
- Entrepreneurship/Business2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Media Management2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/3
- Consulting/Fundraising/Project Management2021 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/3
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/6
- Technology Product Development and Business Strategy2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Business (e-commerce, gourmet food delivery)2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/5
- Business2020 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/3
- Quantitative Analysis/Emerging Markets Trading and Risk Management2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Business (Oil and Gas/Banking)2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 5/7
- Retail Business Consulting2020 · case remanded · criteria 2/3
- Business (Construction CMS Consultant)2020 · case remanded · criteria 0/3
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Education/Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/4
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Event Management2020 · case remanded · criteria 0/0
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/5
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/3
- Business (Venture Capital)2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/3
- Systems Analysis (specifically ERP Systems Analyst specializing in Product Life Management (PLM) and Business Intelligence (BI))2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/4
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 4/6
- Executive Accountant and Auditor2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 3/4
- Construction Management2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Business/Finance2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/7
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Finance/Accounting2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/3
- Business2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/6
- Sponsor-Investigator (unspecified)2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/1
- Foreign Trade Executive2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/6
- Business (Principal Business Consultant)2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 0/0
- Event Management2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/6
- Business and Financial Technology2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 1/4
- Healthcare Strategy and Effectiveness / Management Analysis2020 · appeal dismissed · criteria 2/4
FAQ
- How do EB-1A appeals in Business usually end?
- Of 143 cases in the base: 106 dismissed (74%), 33 remanded (23%), 4 sustained (3%). These are appeals - mostly denials; you cannot derive visa approval odds from them.
- Which criteria are counted most often in Business?
- Counted most often: Leading role (57), Judging (44), Published material about you (35). NOT counted most often: Awards (64), Original contribution (60), Published material about you (50).
Related
Approval stories
Other fields
Based on: 1,242 AAO EB-1A appeal decisions · issued Jan 2020 - Feb 2025 · USCIS: AAO non-precedent decisions · all decisions
Sources
Public anonymized AAO decisions. Reference information, not legal advice; the appeal sample skews toward denials and does not reflect approval odds.