Skip to content

Critique Open Research & Review: does a paper here count for EB-1A and O-1?

Key answer

Journal Critique Open Research & Review: tier 3. It fits the authorship criterion if your article is peer-reviewed, substantive and in your field; the tier is a reference assessment, not a USCIS decision.

Scholarly journal

A reference card from our catalog.

Tier 3

From the journal's site and the registers

What the journal's site aimjournals.com states and what the registers show. Paraphrased, checked Oct 2, 2026.

Publisher
Publisher: The Pinnacle International Journals, which describes itself as a publication house with 13 peer-reviewed open access journals.
Country
Mauritius: the publisher's editorial office gives Mauritius as its location.
ISSN
eISSN 3023-3267 (printed on the journal page).
Indexing
The journal page says it is currently indexed in Google Scholar and shows "Research Impact Factor = 9.78 (By Research Bib)".
Peer review
The publisher's site states double-blind review of every submission and adherence to COPE guidelines.
Frequency
Per the journal page: 6 issues a year (bimonthly), deadline the 25th; yet its metrics block says "12 time a year" and the call for papers mentions monthly issues.
  • Check: a SCImago (Scopus data) search by ISSN 3023-3267 returns no results.
  • The "Journal Metrics" block: first decision in 14 days, 500+ submissions received, 120 accepted, 25% acceptance, "Impact Factor 4.2" with no source named.

Source: the journal's site aimjournals.com (pages /, /index.php/corr); SCImago Journal Rank (Scopus data), checked Oct 2, 2026; the version on the site applies.

What officers look at: 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) - scholarly article, peer review, readers, indexing

A paper in Critique Open Research & Review goes to the authorship criterion if it is yours and substantive and the journal has reach and indexing: the reputation of Critique Open Research & Review carries no weight without your contribution.

The "Authorship" criterion: what USCIS requires and how to meet itOpen the full catalog

Similar

Documents and templates from the library

Reference information, not legal advice and not a USCIS decision: the final assessment is the officer's.

Why "Scholarly authorship" gets refused

Accepted in 44% of challenged petitions (86 of 196); not an approval rate.

The articles are not shown to be scholarly in nature. Columns, blog posts and round-ups do not satisfy this criterion.

All refusal grounds and the sample