AAO precedent on EB-2 NIW test
Updated: Author: Alina Kanametova
DeepL translation of the AAO precedent Matter of Dhanasar (Dec 27, 2016), the three-prong EB-2 NIW test; citation checked against the original Oct 12, 2026.
Official source of the document ↗verified Oct 12, 2026
About this document
A Russian translation of the AAO precedent decision Matter of Dhanasar, published at 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016). It explains the NIW framework, overturns Matter of New York State Dept. of Transportation, and states a new three-part test for waiving the job offer and labor certification requirements under EB-2. The text also summarizes the case outcome: the appeal was sustained and the petition approved.
Key points
- The AAO sets a three-prong NIW test: substantial merit and national importance of the endeavor, a person well positioned to advance it, and benefit to the US on balance from waiving the job offer and labor certification.
- It explains that EB-2 normally requires a US job offer and a labor certification from the Department of Labor.
- The applicant was a self-petitioning researcher and educator in aerospace engineering; the appeal was sustained and the petition approved.
- Citation: Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), Interim Decision #3882, decided December 27, 2016; it vacated Matter of New York State Dep't of Transp., 22 I&N Dec. 215 (decision text on justice.gov, checked Oct 12, 2026).
- Before the appeal, the Director of the Texas Service Center had found the person qualified as an advanced degree professional but denied the waiver.
- For the second prong the AAO weighs education, skills, knowledge and record of success in similar efforts, a model or plan, progress so far and interest from customers, users, investors or others.
- The AAO does not require proof that the endeavor will more likely than not succeed, but the person must show by a preponderance of the evidence that they are well positioned to advance it.
- The USCIS Policy Manual (vol. 6, part F, ch. 5, current as of Oct 2, 2026) still applies this test and cites Dhanasar for the point that locally or regionally focused endeavors may have national importance.
What is inside
- Citation and decision date
- Holding and case result
- I. Legal framework
- EB-2 and labor certification
- NIW waiver authority
- NYSDOT framework analysis
- II. New analytical framework
When it helps
Useful when you write the NIW argument and want the test in the AAO's own words. Cite the decision by its official citation, take the second-prong factors as a checklist for your evidence, and check any quote against the English original: this is a machine translation.
Source: USCIS / official source. The material opens on the site. Reference material, not legal advice.
This document has a dossier on the site
Related materials
- USCIS Policy Memo PM-602-0005.1 - Evidence Evaluation Methodology for I-140 Petitions (Auto-Translated)Guides
- USCIS memo on INA 245(k) for EB AOSGuides
- EB-2 NIW expert opinion letterGuides
- EB-2 NIW AAO denial of civil engineer appealGuides
- EB-2 NIW AAO Dhanasar appeal decision, 2023Guides
- EB-2 NIW Dhanasar Practice PointerGuides