Real-decisions analysis
We compare your situation against 3000+ real EB-1A AAO appeal decisions (2020+). Learn from real cases - what counted, where they fell short.
Your field
Which criteria you meet
Pick at least one criterion
Data is auto-extracted from public AAO decisions. Reference patterns, not legal advice or a prediction about your case.
What the database is and how to read it
These are decisions of the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on EB-1A - anonymized and public. People reach the AAO after a refusal, so the database consists largely of dismissals and remands: it is not approval statistics and cannot be turned into them.
Its value is elsewhere. Each case shows which criteria were claimed, which were struck out and in what words. That lets you learn from concrete reasons rather than general advice: what exactly was wrong with the evidence, which link was missing, what the officer treated as an assertion without support.
It reads best from your own situation: filtering by field and criterion surfaces cases like yours and the objections that recur in them. That is also the list of things worth closing in advance.
What it cannot tell you
- The share of dismissed appeals is a share among appealed cases, not a probability of refusal on a petition.
- The AAO hears appeals; first-instance service-center decisions are not in the database and their reasoning can differ.
- A similar case does not predict your outcome: comparable materials produce different decisions.
What the chats ask about AAO decisions
- 2×About the appeal
- 1×Appeal after denial on final merits.
Rules and tips from the chats
- common questionAfter an I-140 denial, people often ask about motion to reopen or reconsider options: which forms to file, what arguments and new evidence are needed, and how realistic approval is after review.
Questions and answers on the site
Distilled from the public community chats, anonymised; corpus as of June 2026. These are participants' observations, not legal advice and not USCIS statistics.
Related articles