EB-1A I-140 Notice of Intent to Deny
Updated: Author: Alina Kanametova
An EB-1A NOID: three criteria met, acclaim not shown. The 30-day response time (33 if mailed) and the response rules in the USCIS Policy Manual.
Official source of the document ↗verified Oct 12, 2026
About this document
A USCIS Notice of Intent to Deny on a Form I-140 immigrant petition seeking EB-1A classification as an individual of extraordinary ability in software development. It explains the EB-1A legal standard, reviews the regulatory criteria, and says the record met three criteria but still failed the final merits test. USCIS gives the applicant 30 days, or 33 if mailed, to respond with evidence.
Key points
- A NOID on an I-140 in the EB-1A category (E11, INA 203(b)(1)(A)): no one-time major international award, so the case relies on the criteria.
- Three criteria were accepted: judging, authorship of scholarly articles and a leading or critical role; the major-contribution claim was rejected because the patent and citations did not show impact on the whole field.
- At the final merits step USCIS did not find sustained national or international acclaim and gave 30 days to respond, or 33 if the notice was mailed.
- The maximum response time for a NOID is 30 days; for a mailed NOID 3 days are added, so the response must reach USCIS within 33 days of mailing (USCIS Policy Manual, vol. 1, part E, ch. 6, current as of Oct 2, 2026).
- If the last day falls on a Saturday, Sunday or federal holiday, a response received on the next business day is timely (same chapter).
- With no response the request may be denied as abandoned, on the record, or both; a partial response is a request for a decision on the record (same chapter).
- At the second EB-1A step the officer weighs the whole record, including evidence outside the ten criteria, and decides whether the person is among the small percentage at the very top of the field (Policy Manual, vol. 6, part F, ch. 2).
- An officer may not deny because one type of evidence, for example articles about the person, is absent when other evidence meets three criteria (same chapter).
What is inside
- Intro and petition details
- EB-1A legal standard
- Regulatory criteria list
- NOID basis and response rules
- Criterion-by-criterion findings
- Final merits determination
- Deadline and cover sheet instructions
When it helps
Useful when a NOID arrives on an EB-1A, especially one saying the criteria are met but acclaim is not shown. The sample shows which evidence USCIS accepted and where it refused at the second step. Build the response around the final merits: what shows recognition beyond your own work - citations, adoption, invitations - and send it in one package with the NOID before the deadline.
Source: Community (anonymized). The material opens on the site. Reference material, not legal advice.
Need access beyond the daily limit?
Up to 4 files a day in the viewer above, once your profile is complete. More on request.
Related materials
- AAO precedent on EB-2 NIW testGuides
- USCIS Policy Memo PM-602-0005.1 - Evidence Evaluation Methodology for I-140 Petitions (Auto-Translated)Guides
- USCIS memo on INA 245(k) for EB AOSGuides
- EB-2 NIW expert opinion letterGuides
- EB-2 NIW AAO denial of civil engineer appealGuides
- EB-2 NIW AAO Dhanasar appeal decision, 2023Guides