EB-1A appeals database
Updated: Author: Alina Kanametova
3000+ real AAO appeal decisions on the EB-1A talent visa for 2020-2025. Transparent, with search and filters: which criteria were counted, how often that led to success, and the words used to deny.
This is an open base you can search. Need a personal analysis of your specific situation? Analysis of real decisions.
These are appeal decisions - mostly denials and remands (80% dismissed). These are not visa approval odds, but a base to learn from real reasons. Not legal advice.
Meeting the criteria != approval.
EB-1A is assessed in two stages: first the formal criteria (3 of 10 needed), then a final assessment of the whole. Below you can see how often each criterion was counted and how rarely that led to passing the final assessment.
Concretely: 510 cases never reached the final-merits stage (not enough criteria), while 699 reached it - and were still denied there. That is the answer to “I have 3 criteria”: criteria are only the gate; the whole picture decides.
How each criterion was assessed
counted / not counted / not claimed
Even when this criterion is counted, only 4% of such cases reach a passing final assessment.
Show these decisionsEven when this criterion is counted, only 4% of such cases reach a passing final assessment.
Show these decisionsEven when this criterion is counted, only 11% of such cases reach a passing final assessment.
Show these decisionsEven when this criterion is counted, only 6% of such cases reach a passing final assessment.
Show these decisionsDecisions by year
* 2025 is a partial year - the latest in the base, still being published. Its height is not comparable with the years before it.
Latest AAO decisions
These are appeal decisions, mostly denials: they are for learning from real reasons, not for computing approval odds. Each summary was produced automatically; check the PDF. The counters cover only the decisions in this feed: each category starts on the date shown in its card, not on January 1.
EB-1A · 2026
60
in the feed since Jul 24, 2026: dismissed 45, sustained 0
EB-2 NIW · 2026
56
in the feed for all of 2026: dismissed 52, sustained 0
O-1 · 2026
9
in the feed for all of 2026: dismissed 8, sustained 0
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards- Membership- Media+ Judging- Original contribution+ Exhibitions- Leading role- High remuneration- Commercial success
The petitioner failed to satisfy at least three of the ten initial evidentiary criteria, so the AAO did not reach the final merits determination.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a photographer and multimedia artist, sought EB-1A classification claiming recognition in photography and visual arts. The AAO found only two of ten criteria satisfied (judging and exhibitions), while awards, membership, published material, and high salary were not met due to conflicting evidence, uncertified translations, and flawed wage comparison methodology. The appeal was dismissed and the final merits determination was not reached.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards- Membership+ Judging- Original contribution+ Authorship+ Leading role+ High remuneration
The AAO confirmed that although the petitioner formally satisfied four criteria, the totality of evidence failed to demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim and being among the small percentage at the very top of the field.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
A physician specializing in renal medicine filed an EB-1A petition claiming seven criteria. USCIS and the AAO found four criteria satisfied (judging, authorship, leading role, high salary), but in the final merits determination deemed the evidence insufficient: support letters contained only general praise, publications had very low citation counts (14 works, 20 total citations), and awards and memberships were not shown to require outstanding achievements. The reader can learn that meeting the minimum number of criteria does not guarantee approval without compelling evidence of sustained acclaim at the very top of the field.
- EB-1Aappeal remanded+ Awards
USCIS failed to properly evaluate the evidence by addressing unclaimed criteria, ignoring claimed ones, mischaracterizing registered patents as provisional, and improperly applying the final merits analysis at the initial criteria stage.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, an automotive engineer and entrepreneur, claimed multiple EB-1A criteria including awards, membership, original contributions, authorship, exhibitions, leading role, and high salary. USCIS found only the awards criterion met and denied the rest. The AAO found that USCIS evaluated an unclaimed criterion, failed to address claimed evidence, mischaracterized registered patents as provisional, and conflated the two-step Kazarian framework, and remanded for a new decision.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish the national importance of his proposed endeavor because the evidence demonstrated the importance of the industry as a whole rather than the prospective impact of the specific endeavor.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner proposed to develop biomechanical models for non-invasive study of hearing functionality. The AAO found substantial merit but rejected national importance, noting that recommendation letters and statistics addressed the importance of the industry rather than the specific endeavor's prospective impact. The appeal was dismissed and the remaining Dhanasar prongs were not reached.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed+ Awards+ Media+ Authorship+ Exhibitions+ Leading role- Comparable evidence
The petitioner met the minimum threshold of three initial criteria but failed to demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim or that she is among the small percentage at the very top of her field.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a fitness specialist and professional bodybuilder, filed an EB-1A petition. USCIS found five initial criteria satisfied, but the final merits determination concluded there was no sustained national or international acclaim or evidence of being at the very top of the field. The AAO affirmed the denial, finding that competition results, publications, and media coverage were insufficiently contextualized and did not distinguish the petitioner from other professional athletes.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards- Membership- Media- Judging- Commercial success
The petitioner failed to satisfy the threshold requirement of at least three of the ten regulatory criteria, so the AAO did not reach the final merits determination.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a communications and audiovisual media specialist, sought EB-1A classification claiming seven criteria. The AAO found none of the discussed criteria satisfied: the award lacked national or international recognition, memberships were not properly evidenced, publications lacked required elements, roles did not constitute judging, and commercial success was not shown comparatively. The AAO declined to reach the remaining claims because the numerical threshold of three criteria was not met.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to demonstrate that his proposed endeavor of advancing sustainable architecture and urban design had national importance, as the recommendation letters offered only conclusory statements without corroborating evidence of broader implications beyond his routine employment duties.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, an architect with a master's degree in urban planning, filed an EB-2 NIW petition claiming his endeavor of advancing sustainable architecture and urban design through energy-efficient public building projects had national importance. The AAO agreed the endeavor had substantial merit but found it did not extend beyond routine employment duties or demonstrate broader implications for the field or nation. Recommendation letters were deemed insufficient due to conclusory statements lacking corroborating evidence linking the petitioner's work to national-level impact.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards- Media+ Judging+ Authorship- Leading role
The appeal was dismissed because the petitioner failed to meet the three-criterion threshold: the claimed award was not established as a distinct prize for excellence in the field, the media articles concerned a competition rather than his scholarly work, and the distinguished reputation of the organizational division was not demonstrated.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
A doctoral student in mathematics filed an EB-1A petition claiming five criteria. The AAO confirmed two criteria (judging and authorship of scholarly articles) but rejected three others: the claimed award was not established as a distinct prize for excellence in the field, over 20 articles about a student competition did not constitute published material about his scholarly work and were syndicated, and the distinguished reputation of the organizational division was not proven independently of the parent organization. The final merits determination was not reached due to failure to meet the initial evidence threshold.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish the national importance of her proposed endeavor in financial risk management, as her assertions were non-specific and based on mere general alignment with national priorities of regulatory agencies without demonstrating a concrete broad national-level impact.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a financial risk specialist, filed an EB-2 NIW petition claiming her work on strengthening regulatory risk frameworks had national importance. The AAO agreed the endeavor had substantial merit in business but found no evidence of national importance: plans were vague, it was unclear where she would work, and her single scholarly publication had no citations or evidence of field impact. A reader can learn that mere alignment with federal agency priorities without concrete evidence of broad national-level impact does not satisfy the first Dhanasar prong.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards- Membership+ Judging- Original contribution+ Authorship- Leading role
The petitioner failed to satisfy at least three of the ten initial evidentiary criteria under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), precluding a final merits determination.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, an education researcher, sought EB-1A classification citing awards, memberships, original contributions, and a leading role. The AAO found that the awards and grants did not constitute recognized prizes for excellence, the memberships did not require outstanding achievements, the original contributions lacked documentary corroboration, and the leading role was not established. Readers can learn that recommendation letters without supporting documentary evidence and research grants funding future work do not satisfy the relevant criteria.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish that her proposed endeavor as a cardiovascular clinical research coordinator has national importance, as the evidence did not demonstrate prospective impact beyond her employer.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a clinical research coordinator and sub-investigator on a cardiovascular research team, sought an EB-2 NIW claiming her work optimizing structural heart clinical trials and expanding minority participation had national importance. The AAO found substantial merit but not national importance, noting the absence of independent citations, concrete expansion plans, and expert letters linking her work to national initiatives. On appeal, the petitioner submitted no new evidence, merely resubmitting materials already in the record.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish that his proposed supply-chain consulting endeavor has national importance, as the business plan contained arbitrary and unsubstantiated financial forecasts and hiring plans, and the endeavor would only benefit individual clients without broader implications.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, describing himself as a production coordinator, filed an EB-2 NIW petition based on a plan to establish a supply-chain consulting company for small and medium enterprises. The AAO found that the business plan contained arbitrary and unsubstantiated financial forecasts and hiring plans, undermining the reliability of the entire record, and that the proposed endeavor would only benefit individual clients without demonstrating broader implications. Because the first Dhanasar prong was not met, the AAO declined to reach the second and third prongs and dismissed the appeal.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish that his proposed cybersecurity endeavor rises to the level of national importance, and new evidence submitted on motion did not alter that finding.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
A cybersecurity professional filed combined motions to reopen and reconsider a previously dismissed EB-2 NIW appeal. The AAO confirmed that substantial merit was established but national importance was not, as the petitioner failed to show his specific work extends beyond his employer to impact the broader field. New evidence submitted on motion was not tied to his specific endeavor and did not change the outcome.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to establish the national importance of the proposed endeavor because the evidence showed prospective impact limited to the employer and its clients, and contained inconsistencies between the initial petition and the appeal regarding the field of impact.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a mechanical engineer with a PhD, proposed to continue research on failure mechanics of soft materials and composites. The AAO found substantial merit but not national importance: the initial petition referenced biomedical and aerospace applications while the appeal shifted to semiconductors without resolving the discrepancy with independent evidence. Recommendation letters described past projects rather than the prospective impact of the proposed endeavor.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance+ Prong 2: well positioned
The petitioner failed to establish the national importance of his proposed endeavor in orthopedics and traumatology, as the recommendation letters and articles did not demonstrate broad impact on the U.S. medical field at a level commensurate with national importance.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, an orthopedic surgeon with nearly forty years of experience, claimed his endeavor to revolutionize hip pathology treatment through minimally invasive surgery, physician training, and new care protocols had national importance for the United States. The AAO agreed the endeavor had substantial merit and that the petitioner was well-positioned to advance it, but found he failed to provide sufficient evidence that his specific activities would broadly impact orthopedics and traumatology at a national level. The recommendation letters contained only general assertions of national importance without corroborating data, and the submitted articles did not discuss the petitioner's specific endeavor.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed+ Awards+ Membership+ Media+ Judging+ Original contribution+ Authorship+ Leading role+ High remuneration
The AAO upheld the denial because the totality of evidence did not demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim or that the petitioner is among the small percentage at the very top of her field.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, an AI product manager, filed an EB-1A petition claiming eight criteria. USCIS found four criteria met but denied the petition at the final merits stage, and the AAO upheld the denial. A reader can learn that employer-level recognition, media coverage of employer products without naming the petitioner, and recommendation letters from individuals who never worked with the petitioner using identical language are insufficient to demonstrate sustained acclaim at the very top of the field.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed
The appeal was dismissed because Form I-290B contained an invalid signature - an electronically transposed image rather than the petitioner's personal handwritten signature.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner appealed a denial of an EB-2 NIW petition. The AAO found that the signature on Form I-290B was an electronically transposed image identical to the signature on Form G-28 and not a valid personal signature. Because the signature issue was dispositive, the AAO did not reach the merits of the Dhanasar criteria.
- EB-1Aappeal remanded+ Awards+ Exhibitions+ Leading role
The AAO found the petitioner met the exhibitions criterion through musical performances at concert venues and award shows, bringing the total to three criteria, and remanded the case for a final merits determination.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
A musician (clarinetist in a band) filed an EB-1A petition claiming seven criteria. USCIS recognized only two (awards and leading role), and the AAO added a third - exhibitions - finding that concert performances and award shows qualified as artistic showcases. The case was remanded for a final merits determination that USCIS had not previously conducted.
- EB-2 NIWappeal dismissed- Prong 1: merit and importance
The petitioner failed to demonstrate that his proposed endeavor in healthcare data science has national importance, as the benefits of his work appeared to flow primarily to his specific employer rather than to the field at large.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, a senior data scientist with a PhD in mechanical engineering, sought EB-2 classification with a national interest waiver for his work in predictive analytics and AI in healthcare. The AAO agreed that while the endeavor had substantial merit, the petitioner failed to show how his specific work would produce broader implications beyond his employer rising to the level of national importance. A reader can learn that working in an important industry or on a platform with national reach is not, by itself, sufficient to establish the national importance of a proposed endeavor.
- EB-1Aappeal dismissed- Awards+ Membership+ Media- Original contribution- Leading role
The petitioner failed to meet the initial evidence threshold because he satisfied only two of the ten regulatory criteria (membership and published materials), while at least three are required.
Decision PDF on uscis.govMore
The petitioner, working in regional strategy and public diplomacy, filed an EB-1A petition claiming seven criteria. The AAO found only two criteria satisfied - membership and published materials - and rejected claims regarding awards, original contributions, and leading role, falling short of the three-criterion threshold. The final merits determination was reserved because the initial evidence threshold was not met.
Source: USCIS, AAO non-precedent decisions · feed updated Nov 4, 2026 · 179 decisions in the feed, 20 of them on this page
Why cases were denied: patterns
Real reasons grouped into themes. Themes overlap (one decision can hit several). These are appeals - learn from the patterns, do not read them as odds.
General: assertions not supported by evidence1006 decisions (81%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence of ongoing national or international recognition and did not fulfill the requirements for extraordinary ability, particularly lacking at least three qualifying criteria as specified in the regulations. The requests to review or reopen the case were rejected due to this shortcoming.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough proof of ongoing recognition in the arts, even though they were acknowledged as an athlete. The information about their participation in a performance and earnings did not show that they belonged to the elite tier of their profession.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough proof of ongoing recognition at a national or international level, nor did they show that they are part of a very elite group in their profession. The submitted materials, such as judging experience and publications, did not satisfy the stringent criteria needed for this classification.
Lost at final merits (totality)564 decisions (45%)
- Generalized wording
The initial rejection was due to a lack of evidence showing ongoing recognition at a national or international level and not being in the top tier of the field. However, upon further examination, it was determined that the criteria had been satisfied.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence of ongoing recognition at a national or international level and did not satisfy the necessary requirements for extraordinary ability, particularly not meeting at least three specified criteria. The requests to review or reopen the case were rejected due to this lack of evidence.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough proof of ongoing recognition in the arts, even though he had success in sports. The information about his participation in a performance and earnings did not show that he belonged to the elite group in his area.
Awards not nationally/internationally recognized428 decisions (34%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three out of ten necessary criteria to prove extraordinary ability, particularly in areas such as awards, judging roles, significant contributions, and key positions. The submitted evidence did not show ongoing recognition at a national or international level.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence of receiving a significant international award or fulfill at least three of the required criteria, failing to prove that their achievement was a major award and lacking adequate proof of membership in an acceptable organization.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough evidence to satisfy at least three requirements for exceptional talent, particularly in areas such as memberships, published works, and a significant role. Although one requirement was fulfilled, it was not adequate on its own, and there were also procedural problems with the request.
Original contribution: impact not shown410 decisions (33%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough evidence to show that they satisfied at least three out of the ten specified criteria for the visa category, particularly in terms of published works, unique contributions, and commercial success. The review determined that the submitted information was inadequate to prove ongoing recognition at a national or international level.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three out of ten necessary criteria to prove extraordinary ability, particularly in areas such as awards, judging, significant contributions, and pivotal roles. The submitted evidence did not show ongoing national or international recognition.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide proof of a significant, globally acknowledged award or meet a minimum of three out of the ten required criteria. In particular, the applicant could not show that their victory in a competition was considered a major international accolade, nor did they sufficiently prove membership in an eligible organization.
Judging not actually performed / proven169 decisions (14%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough evidence to show ongoing recognition at a national or international level, nor to prove that they are among the elite in their profession. The submitted materials, such as experience as a judge, academic publications, and prominent positions, did not satisfy the stringent criteria for this classification.
- Generalized wording
The individual did not provide sufficient proof of ongoing recognition at a national or international level, nor did they show they are part of the elite group in their profession. Although they satisfied three preliminary criteria, the overall evidence did not reflect a career marked by notable achievements.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three out of ten necessary criteria to prove extraordinary ability, particularly in areas such as awards, judging, significant contributions, and essential roles. The submitted evidence did not show consistent recognition at a national or international level.
Outlet not shown to be major media96 decisions (8%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to satisfy at least three of the ten criteria necessary for the EB-1A classification, only meeting the requirement related to evaluating the work of others and lacking proof of recognized awards or relevant memberships.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough proof that memberships in the specified organizations necessitate exceptional accomplishments, nor did they adequately show that the published content appeared in prominent media. The case was sent back for additional evaluation of the key role requirement and the criteria for lesser awards.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three required criteria related to exceptional accomplishments and published work in prominent media. The review determined that the provided evidence did not prove the existence of 'outstanding achievements'.
Membership does not require outstanding achievement69 decisions (6%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide adequate proof that the memberships necessitate exceptional accomplishments and lacked sufficient evidence to show that the published material was featured in prominent media. The case was sent back for additional evaluation of the key role and lower award criteria.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three required evidence criteria, particularly concerning membership in prestigious organizations and published works in significant media outlets. The review found that the submitted documentation did not prove exceptional accomplishments.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy a minimum of three necessary criteria to prove extraordinary ability. In particular, the review determined that the evidence provided was inadequate to confirm membership in organizations that necessitate exceptional accomplishments and relevant published work.
Published material not ABOUT the person35 decisions (3%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide evidence that the submitted materials were featured in significant professional or trade publications, as the articles either did not pertain to the applicant or were from lesser-known sources.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not satisfy at least three of the ten necessary criteria for the EB-1A classification, lacking adequate proof of notable awards, association memberships, published works, and original contributions.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to show membership in organizations that necessitate exceptional accomplishments, nor did they present published works or significant original contributions in their area of expertise.
Exhibit / evidence formatting problems30 decisions (2%)
- Generalized wording
The review did not take into account properly certified translations of documents in other languages, resulting in important evidence being overlooked. The case is sent back for a reevaluation.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough initial evidence to show either a significant, globally acknowledged award or fulfill three of the ten specified criteria. In particular, the submitted published materials did not adequately demonstrate extensive media distribution.
- Generalized wording
The applicant provided modified translations of documents, indicating dishonesty, and failed to show a commitment to pursue work in their area of expertise in the country. Additionally, the applicant chose not to contest other evidence requirements.
Recommendation letters too weak / not independent16 decisions (1%)
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide enough proof of ongoing recognition at a high level in the dressage field, either as a competitor or a trainer. Additionally, the evidence of unique contributions was considered inadequate due to doubts regarding its authenticity and significance.
- Generalized wording
The case was sent back for further review because the initial evaluation did not adequately address the main issues and failed to allow the applicant enough chance to provide supporting evidence for claims related to recognition prior to 2015.
- Generalized wording
The applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to show that they satisfied at least three criteria for extraordinary ability, particularly lacking proof that their scientific contributions were significantly impactful in the relevant field.
Dangerous criterion combinations
Real appeal statistics: even when one criterion is counted, failing the second almost always sinks the case. Check whether you are leaning on such a pair.
Judging counted, but Original contribution - not
0 approved of 239 cases in the base (0%)
Authorship counted, but Original contribution - not
0 approved of 206 cases in the base (0%)
Judging counted, but Media about you - not
1 approved of 178 cases in the base (1%)
Judging counted, but Leading role - not
1 approved of 162 cases in the base (1%)
Judging counted, but Memberships - not
1 approved of 160 cases in the base (1%)
Authorship counted, but Media about you - not
1 approved of 107 cases in the base (1%)
Search the decisions
Filter by field, criteria, year and outcome. Search the text of real denial reasons.
Decisions by field
- Arts343 cases
- Beauty19 cases
- Business143 cases
- Education20 cases
- Engineering94 cases
- IT69 cases
- Marketing47 cases
- Other219 cases
- Science155 cases
- Sports133 cases
Archives by criterion
Officer desks
The officer number on your notice is an adjudicating desk. We summarized which criteria each desk questioned most.
What worked in approved cases
Real approved cases (anonymized): field, whether it drew an RFE, what worked, and the key evidence. Orientation, not a guarantee.
Personal analysis
Compare your situation with similar cases in the base.
Breakdown of the 10 criteria
Exactly what each EB-1A criterion requires.
Based on: 1,242 AAO EB-1A appeal decisions · issued Jan 2020 - Feb 2025 · USCIS: AAO non-precedent decisions · all decisions
Sources
FAQ
Are these EB-1A approval odds?
No. These are AAO appeal decisions - mostly denials and remands (80% dismissed). You cannot use them to compute an overall visa approval rate. This is a base for learning from real denial reasons and seeing which criteria are assessed and how.
Where does the data come from?
3000+ public decisions of the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on EB-1A for 2020-2025 (the base is continuously updated). The data is anonymized and contains no personal information.
Why does meeting the criteria not guarantee approval?
EB-1A is assessed in two stages: first the formal criteria are counted (at least 3 of 10), then a final assessment of the totality (final merits). Applicants often meet 3+ criteria but lose at the final assessment. The base shows this clearly for each criterion.