Did I get denied if I received an RFE?

No. An RFE is a request for additional evidence: the officer did not see proof for a specific point and is giving you time to provide it. A denial happens only if you do not respond on time or your reply does not address exactly what was asked. A NOID is a more serious signal: the officer is already leaning toward denial and explains why.

My case status hasn't changed in months. Is this normal?

A long period of silence does not mean there is a problem: USCIS publishes processing timeframes by form and service center. Focus on the receipt date and current processing times for the center handling your case, not the lack of tracker updates.

My petition was approved. When will I get my green card?

For EB-1 and EB-2 NIW, there is a waiting line between petition approval and green card: movement depends on the visa bulletin and your priority date. From there, you will either go through consular processing or adjust status in the US.

After Filing and RFE

Key answer

After you file the petition, you reach a stage where there is very little you can control. That is exactly why people tend to take unnecessary actions here. This section explains what actually happens to your case at USCIS: how to read case statuses, what RFE or NOID means, how to respond, and when your spot in line for a green card will come after approval.

Find Your Scenario

Silence in the tracker, receiving an RFE, getting a NOID, petition approved-these are four different scenarios that require different actions. They are separated below, so there is no need to read the entire section in order.

Silence: Case Accepted, but Nothing Happens

The first thing to do is separate normal waiting time from an actual delay. Focus on your receipt date and the processing times at the service center handling your case, rather than just the feeling that "it's already been a long time."

How to Track Your Case After Submitting O-1/EB-1/EB-2 Petition

Received RFE or NOID

An RFE is not a denial, but a list of what the officer did not find in your package. Handling it comes in three steps: understand why the request was made, collect exactly the evidence being requested, and prepare it in a way that it will be accepted. A NOID means the officer is already leaning toward a denial and requires a much more thorough response.

RFE: What is a Request for Evidence

Why You Get RFEs: Reasons and Statistics

How to Respond to an RFE: Step-by-Step Guide

How to Format Evidence So It Counts

What is a NOID?

RFE Response Should Address the Specific Request

Your response should address what was asked for, not repeat the petition. The material "How to Format Evidence" uses real USCIS request examples and shows why some submissions do not count.

Petition Approved: What's Next

Approval of an EB-1 or EB-2 NIW petition does not mean a green card tomorrow. Next is the wait in the queue managed by the visa bulletin, and your spot in that line is determined by the priority date. The two tables in the bulletin answer different questions: one shows when you can file your documents, the other shows when you can receive a visa.

What Happens After EB-1 / EB-2 Petition Approval

How to Read the Visa Bulletin for EB-1 and EB-2

Priority Date: How to Find It and What It Means

Final Action Dates and Dates for Filing

What to Do Next

If you are outside the US, your next step is consular processing: NVC, paperwork, and an interview. See the "Go through the interview" and "Get a visa and enter" sections. To understand what requirements most often lead to an RFE, see the "Understand the requirements" section.

Frequently Asked Questions

This is not legal advice

The materials are for general informational purposes and help you organize your own preparation. This is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. USCIS processing times and the visa bulletin tables change monthly. Always check official sources.

Related materials - Wait for the decision

All articles in «Wait for the decision»

Next stepEB-1A appeals databaseLearn from 3,000+ real AAO decisions.

From community discussions

«It's wiser to wait, write articles in the meantime, file a patent, gather strong certificates - and only then file. Conjuring a case out of thin air and rushing it in is not the best move.»
community member · from public community chats
«Under recent USCIS rule changes, scholarly articles don't have to be strictly academic: depending on your field, this can include a conference talk or taking part in exhibitions.»
community member · from public community chats
«Your activity should be ongoing: competitions, judging, media, participating in events - to prove the sustained, continuing nature of your work.»
community member · from public community chats

Personal opinions of community members from public discussions, not legal advice.

Did this answer help?

Open database - you can improve it

Found something off, or know what to add? Select text and hit "Suggest an edit", or propose an article/topic below.